Verified answer

First, congratulations!

You should plan it yourself. It's easy, fun and you can get a better deal. I highly recommend Playa Del Carmen, Mexico and stay at the all inclusive RIU. My friends just got back and they like it MORE than Hawaii and they travel the world. Jamaica is my #2 pick.

Just use Orbitz but stay on top of it, keep checking back, google to research high and low seasons, ask the cruise boards or other forums for top recommendations. these days, with the internet, travel agencies are a dying breed as they are completely NOT necessary.